• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • About Us
  • Recipes
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • My Account
  • 0 items - $0.00
High Plains Spice Company

  • Herbs & Spices
    • Herbs & Spices A-Z
    • Herbs
    • Spices
    • Pepper
    • Flavored Sugars
    • Gourmet Salt
    • Whole Seed
    • Chilies
  • Seasonings
    • Seasonings A-Z
    • Spice Blends
    • Baking
    • Canning & Brining
    • Sausage Seasonings
    • Dip & Dressing Mixes
    • Meat & Grilling
    • Salt-Free Blends
  • Coffee
    • Coffee A-Z
    • Light Roast
    • Medium Roast
    • Dark Roast
    • Decaf Coffee
    • Flavored Coffee
    • Organic & Fair Trade
    • Hot Cocoa
  • Tea
    • Tea A-Z
    • Black Tea
    • Green Tea
    • White Tea
    • Herbal Tea
    • Oolong Tea
    • Infusers
  • Extracts
    • Vanilla
    • Natural Flavorings
    • Food Coloring
  • Oils & Balsamic
    • Olive Oil
    • Balsamic Vinegar
    • Specialty Oils
    • Dressings & Marinades
    • Hot Sauce
    • Pour Spouts
    • Honey
    • The Real Dill
  • Gifts
    • 4 Jar Set
    • 8 Jar Set
    • 12 Jar Set
    • Kitchen Tools
Traditional Deviled Eggs

Traditional Deviled Eggs

Nothing beats a down-home traditional deviled egg. They always remind me of large dinners with the entire extended family at Easter! This traditional deviled egg recipe is simple to follow, and really allows for you to play with the ingredients if you so desire. Bon appétit!

Prep Time:
10 min
Cook Time:
15 min
Total Time:
25 min

This Recipe is: Dairy Free, Gluten Free, Vegetarian

Meal Type:Appetizer

Cuisine Type: French

Share Your Recipe on Our Website

Ingredients:

  • 6 large eggs
  • 2-4 tbsp mayonnaise
  • 1 tsp white vinegar
  • 1 tsp yellow mustard (or dijon)
  • 1 tsp pig tickle
  • ½ tsp ground black pepper (or more if you like pepper)
  • 1 tsp white sugar
  • smoked paprika

Directions:

  1. Add eggs in a single layer to a pot. Cover eggs with water (at least 1 ½ inches of water covering eggs) Bring to a boil over high heat. Reduce heat to medium-low and boil for one minute. Remove pot from heat and cover with lid. Leave alone, covered, for a full 14 minutes! After the time has passed, remove eggs from pot (careful as water is still hot), and cool the eggs by running cold water over them.
  2. Carefully crack the shells and peel all eggs. It may help to peel under running water to keep shell pieces off the eggs. After all eggs are peeled, rinse, dry, then slice each egg length wise.
  3. Scoop out all yolks into a bowl. Place the cooked egg whites onto a serving platter. Crumble egg yolks together with a fork. Add 2 tbsp mayonnaise along with all of the vinegar, mustard, pig tickle, pepper, and sugar to the egg yolks. Mix well. Assess the yolk mixture consistency. If too dry, add more mayonnaise until you reach desired consistency.  Taste the mixture.  Add more spices as needed.
  4. With a spoon, evenly refill all of the egg whites with the yolk mixture. Alternatively, you can use a piping bag. Or, for even more fun, add the yolk mixture to a zip lock bag, cut one corner of the bag off with scissors, and use the zip-lock bag as a piping bag! Disperse all of the yolk mixture evenly among all of the egg whites.
  5. Sprinkle smoked paprika over the eggs (alternately, try sprinkling chipotle powder instead of paprika!)  Enjoy!

Related Products

  • ground-black-pepper

    Ground Black Pepper

    $3.50 – $18.50
    Add To Cart
  • smoked-paprika

    Smoked Paprika

    $3.25 – $15.00
    Add To Cart
  • pig-tickle

    Pig Tickle

    $3.40 – $15.00
    Add To Cart

Footer

Map of High Plains Spice Company's location

High Plains Spice Company

312 Main St,
Sterling, CO 80751
(866) 570-1425

Facebook Google + Pinterest Twitter

join the club and save - get exclusive coupons and recipes in your inbox

new product

Check Out These New Products!

  • apple pie a la mode Apple Pie à la Mode $14.29
  • apple pie a la mode Salted Caramel Macchiato $14.29
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy & Terms of Service
  • Refund & Return Policy

© 2025 High Plains Spice Company · Website by Road Warrior Creative

×
Item Added to your Cart!
There are no products
Continue Shopping